Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Thomas del Vasto's avatar

Yeah imo the way meditation is being taught in the West is often criminally bad. Add in the avoidant part and you have a really terrible mix: https://intimatemirror.substack.com/p/the-avoidant-dharma

Speaking as someone who did have a really horrid nihilistic break from a lot of Sam Harris style "Waking Up" meditation.

I've turned back to Christianity as a result and found that the Christian mystical / contemplative tradition is actually much more suited to me, as a whole. It is in some ways less developed but I think perhaps less dangerous because of that?

Also the truth of a loving God who cares for you personally does a lot to help during the Dark Night periods. The term Dark Night also comes from a Christian mystic as well, St. John of the Cross.

Arbituram's avatar

I think you underrate the dangers of even moderate meditation for some people.

Sometimes people talk about meditation as fixing people, or making them happier, but that's not it, even at moderate levels: meditation shifts your personality in a given direction.

Most people , and I think this is uncontroversial, are overly attached to their own emotions and reactions as being equivalent to a true self, and need help to achieve a greater level of equanimity and dissociation from their own feelings .

A subset of people (I have no idea how many, somewhere in the 1-10 percent range) are already too far in that direction, and meditation is actively harmful in being well balanced and functional. My default state is something akin to "third person observer" of my own self, I can be too unreactive, I'm probably top decile in focus, and I have an extremely non-addictive personality.

I've read accounts of people like me starting to do meditation partially because it seems easy; improvements on an axis you're already good at! But it's not actually positive from a "dealing with humans and the world" perspective.

24 more comments...

Ready for more?